State Senate Caps Lifetime Welfare Benefits At Four Years

Other episodes in this series: 
IPR News Features
Date: 
July 14, 2011

By Rick Pluta

The Michigan Senate has approved a four-year limit on cash assistance welfare benefits. The 48-month cap is part of Republican plans to balance the state budget.

Come October 1st, 12,600 families will likely lose benefits averaging a little more than $500 dollars a month. The measure is expected to win the approval of the state House and Governor Rick Snyder, who is relying in the $60 million dollars in savings to keep the budget balanced.  

The vote on time limits broke along party lines.

Democratic state Senator Morris Hood: "What's going to happen to those folks? Where are those 12,000 people going to go the next day?"

"We can't do everything for everybody," says Republican state Senator Mark Jansen. "I think when we say to people, you have a four-year maximum that you can use these services, every month counts and so I think they will be motivated way before four years are over with to go out and start looking for other opportunities."  

Michigan's welfare time limits would be among the strictest in the Midwest. Indiana limits benefits for adults to two years, with no limit on benefits for children.  

Gilda Jacobs, president of the Michigan League for Human Services, says: "We really don't know what the unintended consequences are going to be. I do not believe that the faith community and the non-profit world has the ability to absorb folks who are going to need extra help."

Low-income families will still qualify for food assistance and Medicaid. 

The measure will allow people on public assistance to earn more before losing benefits. It will also exempt parents and spouses caring for a handicapped person from the time limit.

Community Discussion Rules

Comments

I also belive in limit of

I also belive in limit of time you should be on welfare. There are a few people out there that truely do need it though.there are people who regulary look for work and it is very hard to find a job. they say if you look you shall find.But honestly I put in over 20 application a week and don't get 1 call back so I call them and they say I am not what they are looking for. and I am more than willing to work. I got 2 little girl's I don't know what I am going to d!!!

same ol' story

To start most of these people they purpose to cut are the families directly defected by the recession . So lets punish the ones who busted thier rear to try to get ahead. Then one day no job and everything unravels. While a rich bunch of men walk into the sunset laughing. That includes the law maker passing this. How about some of them taking A PAYCUT!!!!!!!

Mississippi needs to adopt this limit

Even a six year lifetime limit would help Mississippi an awful lot. Time to stop rearing generations on generations of cash welfare recipients.

I think that is so unfair.

I think that is so unfair. Since the big wigs scewed up the economy and the poor have to suffer. It's mean and hearthless If the rich had to live half as bad as the poor then this laws would never happen. Take the US ptroblem to the source.Tax the rich, they can afford it. Tax the big corporations, tax the illegal

"Tax the rich, They can afford it"??????

I agreed with you in regards to how the economy is screwed up, which effects the poor but you lost me when you said tax the rich, "they can afford it". Don't you think that is an unfair statement? Soooo, because I went to school, got an education and worked hard for my income, I should then have to take care of the poor because I can afford it. Well, I think some responsibility should be put on individuals. I'm not saying that ppl dont truly need help at some point or another, but there are ppl out there that abuses the system, that have been on assistance for over 10+ years and dont plan on looking for work or won't utilize the system for all the educational opportunities that they provide for free (I wish I could go to school for free). At some point everyone has to stand on their own two feet and if they choose not to, it shouldnt be my responsibility to hold them up. Four years, I believe is enough time to get on your feet.

Taxing the rich

I believe more resources should go to checking out people before they are given anything. Abuses should be punished and the rich should be taxed at the same rate as a person making poverty level, that should triple what a person making over 500K pays now .....just a side note, most of the poor people I know live in housing that anyone would call substandard, make landlords keep their rentals at an affordable price for the area they are in and in live-able conditions or fine them heavily

Fairness

Isn't it fair to earn your own way? Why should the rich pay for the existence of the poor? Shouldn't each person be responsible for his own well being?

The Rich cannot exist without

The Rich cannot exist without the Poor in a consumer based economy.

i agree and disagree. i am a

i agree and disagree. i am a 28 year old mom of 2 boys. i got a associate's degree in business administration but i cant find a job in it for the past 3 years because i have thousand of people looking for the same job with a whole lot more experience then i do, so i had to go back to what i have a lot experience in which is housekeeping and try progress from there. the 9 $ doesn't do nothing it pays the bills and not all of them, so i need food stamps to feed my family. i don't drink i don't do drugs i have always worked and paid my tax's, so i don't think im taking anything from anybody im just using whats mine and what i paid into. i had bad luck with guys so i am a single mom and im doing the best i can and i think im doing a great job. im not popping kids out just to be getting anything like everybody would like to say after my second son i got my tubes tied cause i don't want no more kids and cant afford them. but im grateful for the system i went through it it got me to go to school and is helping me out 2 feed my kids. i cant speak for everybody but i can speak for me. if its used how its meant, it works.

Time Limit on Welfare

This system was intended as a helping hand, NOT A HANDOUT!!!!!!!!! We have seen generations of families living off the backs of hard working Americans for to long. The saying goes, give a man a fish & you feed him for a day, teach him to fish & you feed him for life. Time to learn how to fish.

Oct 1 isn't exactly four

Oct 1 isn't exactly four years. People on welfare now should get a little more notice than just a few months.

Good Call

I think this is a step in the right direction. People shouldn't expect an unlimited ammount of assistance from the government. It will force people to look to improve their situations. I believe that other states should pass similar laws as a matter of princple.

I completely agree with this.

I completely agree with this. There should be time limits and drug tests for all assistance programs.

Drug tests sound awesome!

Drug tests sound awesome!

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.